What Is Marginal Profit?
Marginal profit is the additional profit a firm earns from producing and selling one more unit of output. In arithmetic terms, marginal profit equals marginal revenue (MR) minus marginal cost (MC). In calculus terms, marginal profit is the derivative of profit with respect to quantity: dπ/dQ = MR − MC. It tells managers whether producing an additional unit increases total profit (positive marginal profit), leaves total profit unchanged (zero), or reduces total profit (negative).
Key formulae
– Marginal profit (discrete): ΔProfit / ΔQ = (ΔRevenue − ΔCost) / ΔQ ≈ MR − MC
– Marginal profit (continuous): dπ/dQ = MR(Q) − MC(Q)
– Profit maximization condition: produce up to Q* where MR(Q*) = MC(Q*); at that point marginal profit = 0
Understanding Marginal Profit
– MR (Marginal Revenue) is the extra revenue from selling one more unit.
– MC (Marginal Cost) is the extra cost of producing one more unit.
– Marginal profit is a marginal concept: it focuses only on the next unit, not average or total profits.
– In perfect competition, price = MR, so firms expand output until price = MC. Competitive pressures drive marginal profit toward zero.
– Marginal profit differs from average profit or net profit: a firm can have positive total profit while marginal profit for the next unit is negative, and vice versa.
How to Calculate Marginal Profit — Practical Steps
1. Gather data
– Collect the revenue and cost at two adjacent production levels (Q and Q+1 for discrete units), or obtain functional forms for TR(Q) and TC(Q).
– Exclude sunk/fixed costs when calculating MC and marginal profit for short-run marginal decisioning — only variable costs matter to the incremental decision.
2. Compute marginal revenue MR
– Discrete: MR ≈ TR(Q+1) − TR(Q)
– Continuous: MR(Q) = dTR/dQ
3. Compute marginal cost MC
– Discrete: MC ≈ TC(Q+1) − TC(Q)
– Continuous: MC(Q) = dTC/dQ
4. Compute marginal profit
– Marginal profit = MR − MC (or ΔProfit/ΔQ)
5. Decision rule
– If MR > MC → marginal profit positive → produce the additional unit (increases total profit).
– If MR = MC → marginal profit zero → optimal production level (no gain from producing extra unit).
– If MR < MC → marginal profit negative → do not produce the additional unit (it reduces total profit).
Worked numeric example (discrete)
– Suppose at Q = 99 units, TR = $9,900 and TC = $7,920.
– At Q = 100 units, TR = $10,000 and TC = $8,000.
– MR = 10,000 − 9,900 = $100.
– MC = 8,000 − 7,920 = $80.
– Marginal profit = MR − MC = $100 − $80 = $20. Producing the 100th unit increases total profit by $20.
Special Considerations
– Sunk and fixed costs: Sunk/fixed costs do not change with the next unit and should not influence the marginal-profit decision. Decisions should be based on incremental costs and revenues.
– Short run vs. long run: In the short run a firm may continue producing even if marginal profit is negative for a unit, if producing covers variable costs and reduces losses relative to shutting down. In the long run, all costs are variable and persistent negative marginal profit would justify exit.
– Multi-product firms: Allocate joint costs carefully; marginal profit for one product can depend on production of another (complementary or joint outputs).
– Information limits: Firms rarely know exact MR and MC in real time; use estimates, recent data, and sensitivity analysis.
– Price setting markets: In imperfect competition, raising output may lower price (MR falls), changing marginal profit dynamics.
Why Firms Care About Marginal Profit
– Optimal output: Marginal profit analysis tells firms how far to expand or contract production to maximize total profit (stop where MR = MC).
– Pricing and product decisions: It can guide pricing, promotional discounts, and decisions on product lines or add-on items.
– Capacity planning: Understanding how MC changes with scale helps firms decide on capacity investments and utilization.
– Resource allocation: Firms can allocate scarce resources to products that generate the highest marginal profit.
When Should a Business Shut Down (Short-Run Shutdown Rule)
– Short-run rule: A firm should continue producing if price (P) ≥ average variable cost (AVC), even if total profit is negative, because producing covers some or all variable costs and contributes toward fixed costs. If P MC; stop expanding when MR = MC; contract if MR < MC (with attention to AVC for short-run shutdown).
6. Consider demand-side effects: will producing more depress market price (affect MR)?
7. Incorporate capacity constraints and potential economies/diseconomies of scale.
8. Review strategic considerations: market share goals, long-term investment, regulatory or competitive moves that justify temporarily accepting lower marginal profits.
9. Document assumptions and run scenario analysis (e.g., price drop, input cost increase).
10. Revisit frequently — MR and MC can change rapidly with market or cost conditions.
Common Pitfalls and Behavioral Traps
– Sunk-cost fallacy: Avoid letting past unrecoverable investments influence marginal decisions.
– Ignoring variable-cost coverage: Don’t conflate zero marginal profit (MR = MC) with the shutdown rule; a firm with price below AVC should suspend operations even if MR = MC at some low output.
– Over-reliance on averages: Average profit can mask marginal conditions that should drive production decisions.
– Data lag: Using outdated cost or price data can mislead marginal calculations — update regularly.
Graphical interpretation (conceptual)
– Plot MC and MR curves. The profit-maximizing output is where the MR curve crosses the MC curve from above. The vertical gap between MR and MC at any Q is the marginal profit; when that gap is zero, profit is locally maximized.
Summary
Marginal profit is a fundamental tool for production and pricing decisions. It is simply MR − MC and tells firms whether producing one more unit helps or hurts total profit. Managers should use marginal profit analysis together with the shutdown rule, careful cost measurement (excluding sunk costs), and scenario analysis to make robust decisions about output, pricing, and investments. In many competitive markets, the pressure to produce up to MR = MC drives marginal profit to zero; firms that cannot achieve nonnegative marginal profit in the long run will exit the market.
Source
– Investopedia, “Marginal Profit,” Dennis Madamba. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/marginal-profit.asp
Continuing from the previous explanation, below is a comprehensive, structured article that expands on marginal profit with additional sections, practical steps, numerical examples, guidance for managers, and a concluding summary.
Sources: Investopedia — “Marginal Profit” (Dennis Madamba), plus standard microeconomic principles consistent with mainstream texts. (See: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/marginal-profit.asp)
What Is Marginal Profit? — quick recap
– Marginal profit = marginal revenue (MR) − marginal cost (MC).
– It measures the additional profit earned (or lost) by producing one more unit of output.
– Under profit maximization in standard microeconomics, firms expand output until MR = MC; at that point marginal profit = 0.
Clarifying important terms
– Marginal Revenue (MR): the additional revenue from selling one more unit. For firms with price-setting power, MR generally falls as quantity increases.
– Marginal Cost (MC): the additional cost to produce one more unit. MC can rise (diseconomies of scale) or fall (economies of scale) with output.
– Average Cost (AC) and Average Variable Cost (AVC): AC = total cost / quantity; AVC excludes fixed costs. Shutdown decisions usually compare price to AVC, not AC.
– Note on terminology confusion: sometimes texts conflate “marginal product” (extra output from additional input) with marginal revenue. For marginal profit analysis we use marginal revenue (MR).
Why managers care about marginal profit
– Guides whether one more unit should be produced.
– Informs profit-maximizing output and pricing.
– Helps detect when increasing scale is no longer beneficial (diseconomies of scale).
– Supports shutdown and capacity decisions when marginal profit is persistently negative.
How to calculate marginal profit — practical, step-by-step
1. Define the range of output to analyze.
2. Estimate your revenue function:
– For each quantity q, compute total revenue TR(q) = price(q) × q.
– Compute MR(q) = TR(q) − TR(q−1) for discrete units, or MR = dTR/dq for continuous models.
3. Estimate your cost function:
– Total cost TC(q) = fixed costs + variable costs(q).
– Compute MC(q) = TC(q) − TC(q−1) for discrete units, or MC = dTC/dq for continuous models.
– Ensure you exclude sunk costs from marginal calculations (they do not change with the next unit).
4. Compute marginal profit for each incremental increase:
– Marginal profit(q) = MR(q) − MC(q) (discrete) or π′(q) = MR(q) − MC(q) (differential).
5. Find the profit-maximizing quantity:
– Produce up to the last unit where marginal profit ≥ 0 and next unit would have marginal profit ≤ 0.
– Alternatively, solve MR(q) = MC(q) when continuous.
6. Conduct sensitivity checks:
– Vary price, input costs, capacity constraints, demand elasticity, and re-check MR and MC.
7. Apply shutdown rule:
– If price (or MR) < AVC for all feasible outputs, consider shutting down in the short run.
Numerical examples (discrete, simple)
Example 1 — Single-product manufacturer (discrete units)
– Suppose current output q (units), with the following TR and TC:
– q = 0: TR = 0, TC = 100 (fixed)
– q = 1: TR = 40, TC = 130
– q = 2: TR = 75, TC = 150
– q = 3: TR = 105, TC = 180
– q = 4: TR = 130, TC = 220
Compute MR, MC, and marginal profit:
– For q = 1: MR(1) = 40 − 0 = 40; MC(1) = 130 − 100 = 30 → marginal profit = 10
– For q = 2: MR(2) = 75 − 40 = 35; MC(2) = 150 − 130 = 20 → marginal profit = 15
– For q = 3: MR(3) = 105 − 75 = 30; MC(3) = 180 − 150 = 30 → marginal profit = 0
– For q = 4: MR(4) = 130 − 105 = 25; MC(4) = 220 − 180 = 40 → marginal profit = −15
Interpretation:
– Produce 3 units — marginal profit is zero at q = 3 (MR = MC). Producing the 4th unit reduces overall profit (marginal profit negative).
Example 2 — Continuous approximation
– Let TR(q) = 200q − 2q^2 (reflects downward-sloping demand), so MR(q) = 200 − 4q.
– Let TC(q) = 50 + 40q + q^2 (fixed cost 50). Then MC(q) = 40 + 2q.
– Solve MR = MC:
200 − 4q = 40 + 2q ⇒ 160 = 6q ⇒ q* = 26.67 units.
– At q*, marginal profit = 0 by construction. Check profit, price, feasibility, and AVC-based shutdown rules as needed.
Marginal profit in different market structures
– Perfect competition:
– Price is given; MR = price (horizontal MR). Firms expand output until P = MC. Marginal profit is zero at the profit-maximizing output if price equals MC.
– Competition erodes economic profits in long run; firms produce where P = MC = minimum AC (zero economic profit).
– Monopoly:
– MR < price because selling more requires lowering price. Monopoly sets output where MR = MC and charges the corresponding demand price. Marginal profit is zero at that optimum; total profit may be positive.
– Oligopoly / monopolistic competition:
– Firms consider rivals’ responses; MR depends on strategic interactions. Marginal profit analysis still applies but must incorporate game-theoretic and dynamic elements.
Shutdown decision and marginal profit
– Short-run shutdown rule: If price (or MR) < average variable cost (AVC) at the profit-maximizing output, continue to shut down production because producing increases losses relative to temporarily halting.
– Relationship to marginal profit:
– If marginal profit is negative at all levels and price < AVC, shutting down minimizes losses.
– If marginal profit is negative for the next unit but overall profit is still positive, the firm may still operate at lower output.
Economies and diseconomies of scale
– Economies of scale:
– When expanding output reduces MC, marginal profit can rise as production scales, all else equal.
– Economies result from spreading fixed costs, learning effects, bulk purchasing, process improvements.
– Diseconomies of scale:
– As output grows beyond an efficient scale, MC can increase (coordination costs, bureaucracy), causing marginal profit to decline and eventually turn negative.
– Managers should identify where MC bottoms out relative to MR and avoid expanding beyond efficient scale without improvements.
Multi-product firms and joint costs
– For firms producing multiple products, marginal profit analysis must allocate shared costs carefully:
– Marginal cost for one product could be affected by production of others (joint or by-product relationships).
– Use incremental analysis: compute the incremental cost and incremental revenue attributable to the marginal change in the specific product while holding other outputs constant (if feasible).
– Pricing and bundling decisions require conjoint MR/MC calculation and awareness of cross-price effects.
Practical steps for managers — how to apply marginal profit analysis in practice
1. Gather accurate data:
– Sales volumes, prices, variable input costs, and capacity constraints.
– Identify fixed vs variable costs. Exclude sunk costs (irrecoverable) when evaluating additional production.
2. Estimate demand elasticity and MR:
– Use historical data, A/B experiments, or econometric demand estimation to derive price-quantity relationship.
3. Estimate cost behavior:
– Use accounting and operational data to build a cost function: TC(q) ≈ F + vq + αq^2 (as an example) or piecewise cost schedules.
4. Use discrete or continuous marginal calculations:
– For batch production, compute discrete differences. For high-volume continuous settings, use derivatives.
5. Run scenario and sensitivity analysis:
– Test how MR and MC respond to changes in input prices, demand shifts, and scale constraints.
6. Consider capacity and timing:
– If scaling up requires capital investment, incorporate transition costs and consider option value.
7. Make the decision rule explicit:
– Produce additional units if MR ≥ MC. Stop expanding when MR = MC.
– If price MR, don’t run overtime.
– SaaS / digital goods: Marginal cost per additional user is low (hosting + incremental support). If MR exceeds the small MC, adding users increases marginal profit — drive growth until demand-based MR falls to MC.
– Airlines: For a near-empty flight, marginal cost of carrying one more passenger is small (fuel and baggage weight effects); sometimes selling at low fares (even below average cost) makes sense if MR > MC and contributes to covering fixed costs.
Concluding summary
Marginal profit is a core decision tool: it tells managers whether making one more unit increases profit. Compute marginal revenue and marginal cost accurately (excluding sunk fixed costs), and expand production while MR > MC. Stop expanding where MR = MC because marginal profit equals zero—this is the local profit-maximizing rule. Real-world application requires estimating demand and cost functions, conducting sensitivity checks, and integrating strategic and multi-period considerations. Moreover, evaluate shutdown decisions against average variable cost and recognize that economies and diseconomies of scale will shape the marginal-cost curve and therefore marginal profit dynamics. Practically, firms should use marginal-profit calculations to make incremental decisions, to prioritize investments that lower MC or raise MR, and to avoid strategic errors driven by sunk costs or measurement errors.
For further reading and a concise primer, see Investopedia’s “Marginal Profit” (Dennis Madamba): https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/marginal-profit.asp
[[END]]