What is a synthetic put?
A synthetic put (also called a synthetic long put, married call, or protective call) is an options/stock combination that replicates the economic payoff of owning a put option. To build one you (1) short the underlying stock and (2) buy a call option on that same stock and lot size. The call limits your losses if the stock rallies while the short position benefits if the stock falls. The result behaves like a long put (subject to interest, dividends, and fees).
Key takeaways
– Structure: short stock + long call (same underlying, same or comparable strike/expiration).
– Purpose: protect a short position from upward moves (insurance) or replicate the payoff of a bought put.
– Best-case profit: stock falls to zero (short makes full decline minus call premium).
– Worst-case loss: limited to the call premium paid (if strike = initial short price).
– Costs/risks: option premium, commissions, margin interest, borrow costs/recall, dividend payment obligations for borrowed shares.
– Greeks/time: long call is hurt by time decay (theta) and helped by rising volatility (vega).
Why the synthetic put works (brief theory)
Put-call parity for European options shows the equivalence between calls, puts, stocks, and bonds:
C – P = S – PV(K)
Rearranged, a put can be synthetically constructed from a call and a short stock (plus cash adjustments for the present value of the strike). In everyday practice, short stock + long call produces the same directional and limited-upside profile as a long put (ignoring interest/dividend adjustments and early exercise on American options).
Payoff and example (numeric)
Assume you short 100 shares at S0 = $50 and buy one $50 strike call expiring at the same date. Cost of call premium = $3 per share ($300).
At expiration:
– If ST ≤ $50: call expires worthless. Net P/L = (short gain) − premium = (50 − ST)*100 − 300.
– If ST > $50: short loses (ST − 50)*100 but call pays (ST − 50)*100, so they offset; net P/L = −300 (only the premium paid).
Outcomes:
– Maximum profit: if stock goes to 0 → profit = (50 − 0)*100 − 300 = $5,000 − 300 = $4,700.
– Maximum loss: limited to premium = $300 (if strike = initial short price).
– Breakeven: ST = 50 − 3 = $47 (stock must fall below $47 for net profit).
Practical steps to implement a synthetic put
1. Get the right account
– Ensure you have an approved margin account and options trading permission at your broker. Shorting requires margin and options approval levels.
2. Size the position and run risk calculations
– Decide how many shares to short and buy matching call contracts (1 call = 100 shares).
– Calculate required margin, potential borrow costs, dividend obligations, and maximum potential P/L.
– Choose a strike and expiration that match your objective (see Step 4).
3. Choose strike and expiration
– Strike selection: An at‑the‑money (ATM) call at the short entry price simplifies breakeven and caps the maximum loss roughly to the premium. Using a different strike changes the payoff and breakeven.
– Expiration: Short-term options reduce upfront premium but raise the risk of needing to re-cover or roll the call; longer-term options cost more but give longer protection.
4. Execute the trades as simultaneously as possible
– Ideally place the short sale and the long call as near-simultaneous trades to avoid exposure between trades. Some brokers let you enter a combined order (sell stock + buy option).
5. Monitor and manage
– Track stock moves, option Greeks, borrow availability, margin requirements, and dividends.
– Plan exit: close both positions, let the option protect until exercise/maturity, roll the call forward or close the short, or exercise the call if needed.
Managing and exit strategies
– Close both legs: simplest—buy to cover the short and sell the call.
– Let the call protect through expiration: if stock rallies above strike, the call offsets the short losses.
– Roll the call: if you want continued protection, sell the current call and buy a later expiration (costs and spreads apply).
– Cover the short and keep/sell the call: you may close the short to realize gains and keep the long call as a bullish exposure if you change view.
– Exercise considerations: American calls can be exercised before expiration (rare unless deep ITM before dividend). Understand consequences if exercised.
Costs and risks to consider
– Premium cost: reduces net profit; the call’s premium is the built-in insurance cost.
– Borrow costs and recall risk: borrowed shares for the short may incur fees and can be recalled by the lender, forcing you to cover early.
– Dividends: as short seller you are responsible for paying dividends to the lender.
– Margin interest and maintenance: margin calls possible if the position moves against you and margin is insufficient.
– Early exercise on American options: if the call is deep ITM before an ex-dividend date, the call might be exercised, exposing you to short stock risk, so monitor dividends.
– Liquidity and spreads: wide option or stock spreads can increase trading costs.
– Taxation: short sales and option trades have distinct tax rules; consult a tax advisor.
How volatility and time decay affect the trade
– Vega (volatility): higher implied volatility increases call premium (unfavorable to enter), but if volatility rises after you buy the call, the long call benefits.
– Theta (time decay): the long call loses value over time. If the stock doesn’t move down fast, the option’s time decay reduces protection’s net value.
– Delta: net delta = short stock (delta −1 per share) + call delta (+0 to +1). If call delta ≈ 1 (deep ITM), position is roughly neutral to upward moves; if call delta is small, significant net short exposure remains.
When to use a synthetic put
– You have an established short/bearish view but want limited upside risk for a defined time (e.g., fearing a short-term squeeze or corporate news).
– You want to replicate the payoff of a long put but prefer the mechanics or cash flows of a short stock + call.
– Institutional traders may use synthetics to obscure directional bias while obtaining desired economic exposure.
Alternatives and comparisons
– Buy a put: simpler, no short borrow/margin required. Cost/benefit depends on premium and liquidity.
– Collar: long stock + short call + long put provides downside protection while capping upside—different risk profile.
– Put spread: buy a put and sell another put to lower premium at the cost of capped downside.
– Protective call vs. synthetic put: terminology varies; “protective call” often refers to buying a call to protect a short position (same as synthetic put).
Example checklist before entering
– Verify margin and options approval.
– Confirm shares are available to borrow and check borrow fee.
– Choose strike/expiration and compute breakeven, max gain/loss.
– Confirm total cost (premium + commissions + borrow fees).
– Have an exit/roll plan and stop-loss discipline.
– Consider tax consequences and consult a professional if needed.
Summary
A synthetic put (short stock + long call) is a useful tool to limit upside risk on a short position or to replicate a long put’s economics. It can act like insurance, offering limited maximum loss while preserving large downside potential if the stock falls. But it carries costs (option premium, borrow fees, margin interest) and operational risks (borrow recall, dividends). Understand the mechanics, choose strikes and expirations to match your objectives, and manage the position actively.
References and further reading
– Investopedia, “Long Synthetic,” https://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/longsynthetic.asp
– Options Industry Council, “Put-Call Parity,” https://www.optionseducation.org/strategies/introduction/options_theory/put-call_parity
– Cboe, “Options Basics,” https://www.cboe.com/learn
(If you want, I can run a concrete example with your chosen stock, strike, expiration, and premium to show exact breakeven/margins and expected P/L scenarios.)
(Continuing and expanding the article)
Mechanics and Option-Parity Context
– What the synthetic replicates: A synthetic long put (the position described here) combines a short position in the underlying stock and a long call on the same stock and expiration. At a basic level this position behaves like a long put because the net payoff profile is the same in the economically relevant regions when strike and short entry are aligned. The relationship is a practical consequence of put–call parity for European options (C – P = S – K·e^{-rT}), though in real markets differences in interest, dividends, early exercise (American options), and transaction costs mean the replication is approximate for many traders. (See Investopedia and CBOE for background on parity and option mechanics.)[1][2]
Payoff and P/L — formulas and intuition
Let:
– S0 = short-sale entry price per share
– K = call strike
– c = call premium paid per share
– X = stock price at option expiration
Total position P/L per share at expiration:
– If X ≤ K: P/L = (S0 − X) − c
– If X > K: P/L = (S0 − K) − c
Interpretation:
– Upside (stock rises above K): losses on the short position are exactly offset by the exercised call above K, so the position’s P/L becomes a constant equal to S0 − K − c.
– Downside (stock falls): you keep the full benefit of the short sale less the call premium, so P/L improves as X falls; maximum profit occurs at X → 0 and equals S0 − 0 − c = S0 − c.
Maximum profit and maximum loss
– Maximum profit (per share) = S0 − c (occurs if stock falls to zero).
– Maximum loss (per share) = K − S0 + c (if this value > 0). If K = S0, maximum loss equals the premium c (i.e., the cost of the call). If K K) = (50 − 50) − 3 = −$3 → total = −$300.
So the short-only position would lose $20 per share when stock is $70, but the synthetic put caps that loss at $3 per share.
When to use a synthetic put (practical use cases)
– You are bearish overall and prefer a short position for profit if the stock drops, but you want short-term protection against a spike in price (e.g., ahead of an earnings surprise, takeover rumor, or other event).
– You want downside exposure (profit if stock declines) while limiting the potential large losses if the stock rallies.
– You want to disguise directional bias: combining a short with a call may look different in a portfolio/reporting context than an outright long put or other trades (used at times by institutional traders).
– You prefer to pay only a call premium for protection and can accept the particular payoff characteristics (vs buying a put outright).
Step-by-step: how to implement a synthetic put (practical steps)
1. Confirm your thesis and horizon: choose the time frame (expiration) that matches the period you want protection.
2. Arrange the short:
– Ensure shares are borrowable and check borrow fees.
– Understand margin requirements and locate the stock to short through your broker.
3. Choose the call:
– Strike selection: at-the-money (ATM) will most closely cap upside near your short entry price; out-of-the-money (OTM) will cost less but allow more upside risk; in-the-money (ITM) will cost more and change payoff.
– Expiration: shorter-term reduces premium but increases chance of needing to roll; longer-term costs more but gives longer protection.
– Check liquidity/volume and bid–ask spreads to avoid excessive execution costs.
4. Execute:
– Simultaneously short the stock and buy the call, or do them in quick succession to lock in entry point.
5. Monitor:
– Track dividends and ex-date information (you may be responsible for payments on borrowed shares).
– Be aware of margin calls and broker recall risk (the lender may request shares back).
6. Manage and adjust:
– If protection is no longer needed, you can sell the call and hold or close the short.
– To extend protection, roll the call forward (close and buy a later expiration).
– To remove upside cap, close the call and remain short (exposing yourself to uncapped losses).
7. Close positions:
– At exit, you can buy to close the short and/or sell the call. Avoid attempting to net physically unless your broker supports simultaneous spread orders.
Risks, costs and other practical considerations
– Premium cost: the call premium is a real cost and reduces the position’s net profit on a falling stock.
– Borrow fees and margin interest: short positions may incur borrow costs that can be substantial for hard-to-borrow names.
– Dividends: if the underlying pays a dividend while you are short, you typically must pay that dividend to the share lender.
– Early exercise & American-style options: long calls are not subject to being assigned (the buyer cannot be assigned), but short positions can be unpleasant if the stock lender recalls shares and you have to cover unexpectedly. If you hold American calls, early exercise is possible for the counterparty who’s short the call; long-call early exercise is rarely optimal but its existence affects pricing.
– Transaction costs and slippage: bid–ask spreads, commissions, and implied liquidity should be considered.
– Counterparty and taxation: options and short sales have tax and wash-sale consequences in some jurisdictions — consult a tax professional.
Alternatives and adjustments
– Buy a long put instead: simpler one-contract solution; compares directly to synthetic when all parity assumptions hold. A long put gives the same nominal protection but pays a different premium than the call in many cases.
– Collar (if you already hold stock long): long stock + short call + long put — used to limit downside and upside.
– Vertical spreads with puts or calls: can limit cost and define risk/reward more precisely.
– Replace call with call spread: pay less premium and accept a higher capped payoff if stock rallies further.
Greeks and volatility/time decay
– Vega (volatility): this synthetic gains from increases in implied volatility on the long call—an increase in volatility generally increases call value, which benefits the position’s protection value.
– Theta (time decay): the long call loses time value each day; as expiration approaches, protection erodes unless the call is ATM/ITM.
– Delta: the synthetic’s delta is the sum of the short stock’s delta (-1 per share) plus the call’s delta (+δ), so net delta = −1 + δ. An ATM call has roughly δ ≈ 0.5 at inception, so net delta ≈ −0.5 initially.
– Be mindful: because Greeks move as underlying price moves, the effective protection changes dynamically.
Example comparison: synthetic put vs long put
– Suppose S0 = $50, K = $50, time T short, interest and dividends ignored for simplicity.
– Buy a put K = $50 costs p, or create synthetic by shorting stock at 50 and buying a call costing c.
– Put–call parity (ignoring interest/dividends) implies p ≈ c + K − S0. If K = S0, p ≈ c. In practice, with dividends/interest, p and c will differ—compare total costs including financing and borrow fees before deciding.
How to close or convert the position
– Close short first, hold call: you’ll be long a call (protective long latency).
– Close the call first, hold short: you revert to naked short exposure (uncapped losses).
– Net closing: buy to close the short and sell to close the call in the same session if possible.
– Convert to other positions: e.g., if you decide to be neutral, you could close both and redeploy capital.
When not to use synthetic puts
– If borrow fees are high or shares are hard to borrow.
– If you cannot meet margin requirements or are uncomfortable with recall risk.
– If a long put is cheaper after comparing all fees and taxes — sometimes buying a put outright is simpler and equally effective for pure downside insurance.
Practical checklist before executing
1. Confirm borrow availability and borrow fee.
2. Calculate total expected costs (premium + borrow fees + commissions + margin interest).
3. Choose strike and expiration that match your protection window.
4. Confirm option liquidity (open interest, spread).
5. Understand dividend dates and tax impacts.
6. Prepare exit/adjustment plan and size positions consistent with portfolio risk.
Concluding summary
A synthetic put (short stock + long call) provides a way to preserve the bearish profit potential of a short sale while capping the downside risk from an unexpected price rally. It is commonly used by traders who want “insurance” against upward moves without exiting their short thesis. The strategy’s benefits include a clearly defined capped loss and the possibility of preserving a large portion of the short’s profit if the stock declines. The main costs and risks are the call premium, borrow/margin fees, dividend obligations on borrowed shares, and option time decay. Before using the strategy, traders should weigh total costs, understand how put–call parity and dividends affect equivalence to a long put, and have an exit and adjustment plan.
Sources
1) Investopedia — “Synthetic Put” and related options entries. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/longsynthetic.asp
2) CBOE — options basics and put–call parity educational materials. https://www.cboe.com/education
[[END]]