What is crowdfunding (short definition)
– Crowdfunding is a method of raising capital by collecting relatively small amounts of money from a large number of people, typically via internet platforms and social media. It connects creators, entrepreneurs, or individuals in need with many potential supporters.
Main crowdfunding models (definitions)
– Donation-based: Supporters give money with no expected return (common for medical or disaster relief).
– Reward-based: Backers receive a nonfinancial reward (a copy of the product, a thank-you, or an experience).
– Equity crowdfunding: Backers receive ownership shares or equity in the company; they become investors.
– Debt crowdfunding (peer‑to‑peer lending): Contributors lend money that the campaigner repays with interest.
– Subscription/patronage: Ongoing small payments to support creators (often monthly), common on platforms like Patreon or Substack.
How crowdfunding works (simple process)
1. Choose a funding model (donation, reward, equity, debt, subscription).
2. Select a platform that supports that model (examples below).
3. Set a funding target and campaign length.
4. Create campaign content: description, budget, timeline, and rewards (if any).
5. Promote the campaign through email, social media, press, and existing networks.
6. Collect funds through the platform; deliver promised rewards or comply with investor terms.
Key differences in platform mechanics
– All-or-nothing funding (e.g., Kickstarter): Funds are released only if the campaign reaches its stated goal. This reduces risk for backers.
– Flexible funding (e.g., some Indiegogo campaigns): Campaigners can keep funds as they arrive even if the goal is not met. This gives campaigners more certainty but increases risk for backers.
– Fee structures vary: Platforms commonly charge a percentage of funds raised (typical range ~5%–12%); payment processors may also charge transaction fees.
Regulation and investor protections
– In the U.S., equity crowdfunding and some other models are governed by the JOBS Act (Jumpstart Our Business Startups Act) and overseen by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). These rules set limits on how much nonaccredited (unsophisticated) investors can invest and require intermediaries to be registered.
– Regulations differ across countries; local rules determine what types of crowdfunding are legal and what investor protections apply.
Advantages and disadvantages (concise)
– Pros: Access to a wide pool of potential backers; marketing and customer validation; alternative to bank credit or venture capital; ability to raise funds without giving up control (in reward or donation models).
– Cons: Many startups fail, and backers can lose their money; campaign success requires significant promotion and work; fees and payment processing reduce net proceeds; regulatory requirements and disclosure can be burdensome for equity deals; public exposure can risk idea copying.
Practical checklist for running a crowdfunding campaign
– Pick the right model for your needs and stakeholders.
– Choose a platform whose rules and fees match your campaign (fixed vs. flexible funding).
– Set a realistic funding target and campaign duration.
– Budget fees, payment processing, production, shipping, taxes, and contingencies.
– Prepare clear, honest campaign content: timeline, risks, and use of funds.
– Plan a marketing schedule: email, social media ads, PR, and early backer engagement.
– Prepare to fulfill rewards or investor obligations and keep backers updated.
Small worked example (illustrative)
Assumptions:
– Campaign goal: $20,000 on a platform that charges a 5% platform fee.
– Assume payment processing fees total 3% (note: this is an assumption for the example—confirm actual processor rates with the platform).
Calculations:
– Platform fee = 5% of $20,000 = $1,000.
– Payment processing = 3% of $20,000 = $600.
– Net proceeds = $20,000 − $1,000 − $600 = $18,400.
Backer breakdown:
– If average pledge = $40, number of backers needed = $20,000 / $40 = 500 backers.
– After fees, the campaigner would receive $18,400, which must cover production, fulfilment, shipping, taxes, and any profit.
Warnings and common pitfalls
– Promised rewards must be delivered regardless of amount raised; failure to deliver can damage reputation and may have legal implications.
– Equity and debt crowdfunding carry the same business failure risk as other types of private investment—investors may lose principal.
– Read platform terms carefully: fee types, timing of fund release, refund/chargeback policies, and intellectual property handling.
– Consider tax and regulatory reporting obligations. Local laws vary — check with the relevant regulator or legal counsel if unsure.
Notable platforms (examples)
– GoFundMe: Widely used for personal, medical, and disaster-related fundraising; large user base.
– Kickstarter: Focused on creative and product projects; primarily all‑or‑nothing and reward-based.
– Indiegogo: Flexible options and broader project categories; supports fixed and flexible funding models.
– Patreon/Substack: Designed for ongoing patronage or subscription support to creators.
Historical context and market note
– Crowdfunding grew in prominence after the 2008 financial crisis as entrepreneurs sought alternatives to tightened bank credit.
– The global equity crowdfunding market has been projected to expand rapidly in coming years (source noted below). Market size and growth rates vary by source and time period.
Sources (for further reading)
– Investopedia — Crowdfunding: https
Investopedia — Crowdfunding: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/crowdfunding.asp
Other useful references
– U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) — Crowdfunding (Regulation Crowdfunding): https://www.sec.gov/smallbusiness/exemptofferings/regcrowdfunding
– Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) — Crowdfunding Investor Alert: https://www.finra.org/investors/alerts/crowdfunding
– UK Government — Crowdfunding and peer-to-peer lending: https://www.gov.uk/guidance/crowdfunding-and-peer-to-peer-lending
Practical checklists
Checklist for campaign creators (pre-launch)
1. Define funding model: reward-based, donation-based, equity (investor) or debt. Note legal/regulatory differences for equity/debt.
2. Set a realistic funding target using a cost-first approach (see numeric example below).
3. Choose platform: compare fees, audience, funding model (all‑or‑nothing vs. keep‑what‑you‑raise), and terms.
4. Prepare legal and tax documentation: incorporation, securities/compliance for equity offerings, terms of rewards, VAT/sales tax rules.
5. Build campaign materials: clear value proposition, video, tiered rewards, delivery timeline, and transparent risks.
6. Plan fulfillment and customer support: manufacturing lead times, shipping costs, returns policy.
7. Run a pre-launch (email list, social proof, early backers) to hit momentum on day one.
8. Calculate contingencies (10–30%) for delays, cost overruns, and refunds.
Checklist for backers / investors (due diligence)
1. Verify the platform’s registration and regulatory disclosures (SEC filings for Reg CF offerings in the U.S.).
2. Read the offering documents or campaign page thoroughly: business plan, use of proceeds, timelines, exit assumptions.
3. Assess liquidity: crowdfunding investments are often illiquid; check secondary market availability or lock-ups.
4. Check team and track record: founders’ experience, other projects, verifiable credentials.
5. Evaluate financials and valuation (for equity): revenue, burn rate, projected milestones, reasonableness of valuation.
6. Understand fees and tax implications.
7. Diversify — limit exposure to any single project or issuer.
Worked numeric examples
Example A — Reward-based campaign funding goal
Goal: Launch a hardware product with initial order of 1,000 units.
Assumptions
– Unit manufacturing cost = $10
– Packaging & fulfillment per unit = $5
– Desired gross margin per unit = $5
– Platform fee = 5% of funds raised
– Payment processing = 3% + $0.30 per pledge (use aggregate approximation)
– Contingency = 15% of total costs for delays/overruns
Step 1 — Calculate unit total cost before margin
Unit cost = $10 + $5 = $15
Step 2 — Target gross revenue needed for units (cover cost + desired margin)
Revenue per unit target = $15 + $5 = $20
Revenue for 1,000 units = $20 × 1,000 = $20,000
Step 3 — Add platform and payment fees (approx 8% total)
Fees = 8% × $20,000 = $1,600
Step 4 — Add contingency (15% of costs + fees)
Contingency = 15% × ($20,000 + $1,600) = 15% × $21,600 = $3,240
Step 5 — Funding goal
Funding goal = $20,000 + $1,600 + $3,240 = $24,840
Round up to cover unexpected items — set campaign target at $25,000 or $30,000 depending on marketing costs.
Example B — Equity crowdfunding and dilution
Company pre-money valuation = $2,000,000
Existing shares (founders + employees) = 1,000,000 shares
Company intends to raise = $500,000 via equity crowdfunding
Step 1 — Post-money valuation
Post-money = pre-money + new investment = $2,000,000 + $500,000 = $2,500,000
Step 2 — Price per share (based on pre-money)
Price per share = pre-money valuation / existing shares = $2,000,000 / 1,000,000 = $2.00 per share
Step 3 — Shares to issue to new investors
New shares = investment / price per share = $500,000 / $2.00 = 250,000 shares
Step 4 — Ownership after the round
Total shares after = 1,000,000 + 250,000 = 1,250,000
Investor ownership = 250,000 / 1,250,000 = 20%
Founders’ ownership = 1,000,000 / 1,250,000 = 80%
Founder dilution = 1 – 0.80 = 20% (proportional)
Key risks to highlight
– Illiquidity: many crowdfunding investments cannot be sold easily.
–
– Fraud and scams: some campaigns misrepresent traction, team credentials, or use of proceeds. Crowdfunding platforms screen issuers, but screening standards vary and are not a guarantee against fraud.
– Limited disclosure / transparency: early-stage companies often provide few audited financials and forward-looking forecasts that are optimistic and unverified.
– Valuation risk: pre-money valuations in private rounds are negotiated estimates, not observable market prices. They can be inflated and hard to compare across deals.
– Business (execution) risk: startups have high failure rates; many never achieve product-market fit, scale, or profitable unit economics.
– Dilution risk: future fundraising rounds can reduce your percentage ownership unless anti-dilution protections are in place.
– Concentration risk: investing only in a few crowdfunded deals concentrates idiosyncratic risk; a single failure can heavily damage returns.
– Platform / counterparty risk: platforms can change fees, suspend secondary markets, or go out of business, affecting your ability to monitor or exit investments.
– Regulatory / legal risk: rules vary by country and campaign type (equity, debt, rewards). Restrictions on resale or transfer are common.
– Tax uncertainty: tax treatment depends on instrument (equity vs debt) and jurisdiction; preferential tax treatments (e.g., qualified small business stock) have strict requirements.
How to assess a crowdfunding opportunity — step-by-step checklist
1) Identify the instrument and rights
– Equity (common or preferred), convertible note, safe (simple agreement for future equity), or debt.
– Check voting rights, liquidation preference, anti-dilution provisions, and dividend terms (if any).
2) Read the offering documents
– Prospectus, private placement memorandum, business plan, cap table, and use-of-proceeds statement.
– Note any resale restrictions or investor lock-ups.
3) Evaluate the team and traction
– Founders’ backgrounds, prior exits, time committed, and key hires.
– Customer metrics: revenue runway, monthly recurring revenue (MRR), retention, and unit economics (e.g., customer acquisition cost vs lifetime value).
4) Inspect financials and assumptions
– Historical revenue/expenses, burn rate, cash runway.
– Check assumptions in projections (growth rates, margins); stress-test them (e.g., what if growth is 50% of forecast?).
5) Check valuation and cap table impact
– Use the price-per-share calculation method shown earlier to see dilution scenarios with future raises.
6) Understand exit paths
– IPO likelihood, M&A prospects, or secondary sales. Ask when and how investors can expect liquidity.
7) Confirm platform and regulatory compliance
– Verify platform’s due-diligence procedures and whether the offering is under Reg CF, Reg D, Reg A+, or other rules (U.S. examples given below).
8) Review fees and costs
– Platform fees, legal fees, and carried interest may affect net returns.
9) Seek independent advice when needed
– Legal or tax counsel can clarify complex rights or tax consequences.
Worked diversification example (simple numerical)
– Capital to deploy: $10,000.
– Target number of deals: 20.
– Check size per deal: $10,000 / 20 = $500 per deal.
– Why this helps: with small, equal-sized positions you limit idiosyncratic fallout — one failed company reduces portfolio value by about 5% (500/10,000) rather than a much larger percentage.
Practical red flags (quick)
– Vague or missing use-of-proceeds.
– Lack of key performance indicators (KPIs).
– Founders unwilling to disclose cap table or prior funding.
– Unrealistic financial projections with no sensitivity analysis.
– High founder turnover or dependence on a single customer.
Exit scenarios and resale mechanics
– Most equity crowdfunded shares are illiquid for years. Secondary markets may exist but often have low volume and transfer restrictions.
– Convertibles and SAFEs convert to equity typically at a priced round; understand conversion caps, discounts, and triggers.
– Debt crowdfunding provides scheduled interest and principal repayment but carries issuer default risk.
Regulatory primer (U.S. examples)
– Regulation Crowdfunding (Reg CF): allows retail investors to buy securities through SEC-registered platforms with investment limits based on income/net worth. See SEC resources below.
– Regulation D (Reg D) 506(b/506(c)): private placements to accredited investors (higher-income/asset threshold); fewer disclosure requirements.
– Regulation A+: allows companies to raise up to specified limits with broader public solicitation but with SEC review and disclosure.
Before committing money — quick pre-invest checklist
– Confirm instrument type and investor rights.
– Set an allocation cap per deal (e.g., 1–5% of total investable capital).
– Run the simple valuation/dilution math shown earlier for current and hypothetical future rounds.
– Ensure you have an emergency cash buffer and that crowdfunded capital is money you can lock up.
– Document the expected holding period and potential exit routes.
Three practical tips
1) Treat most crowdfunded equity as speculative and illiquid — size positions accordingly.
2) Keep records: copies of the offering, subscription agreements, and tax documents.
3) Review platform reviews and
and platform fee schedules, regulatory disclosures, complaint records, and whether the platform offers a secondary market or transfer restrictions.
Red flags to watch for
– Promises of guaranteed returns, buybacks, or scheduled liquidity — equity in startups is inherently risky and illiquid.
– Vague use of proceeds or absent financials.
– High founder insider selling immediately after the raise.
– Unusual governance that grants founders disproportionate control (super-voting shares, limited board rights for new investors).
– Opaque fee structures (platform takes carried interest or charges large success fees that aren’t disclosed).
Quick dilution and ownership math (worked examples)
Definitions:
– Pre-money valuation = company value before the new raise.
– Raise amount = new money being invested.
– Post-money valuation = pre-money valuation + raise amount.
– Ownership % = investment / post-money valuation.
Example A — initial investment
– Company pre-money valuation = $5,000,000.
– Company raises $1,000,000.
– Post-money = $6,000,000.
– You invest $10,000. Ownership = 10,000 / 6,000,000 = 0.1667% (≈0.17%).
Example B — later dilution without pro rata rights
– Next round: pre-money $10,000,000; new raise $2,000,000; post-money = $12,000,000.
– Your initial 10,000 shares (or $10,000 stake) become 10,000 / 12,000,000 = 0.0833% (≈0.08%).
– Paper value at round prices: at initial post-money your stake equaled $10,000 (10,000/6,000,000 × 6,000,000). At new post-money implied company value of $12M, your stake’s pro rata value = 0.0833% × $12,000,000 = $10,000 — unchanged in nominal dollars if price per share didn’t change, but your percentage ownership is halved.
Example C — maintaining ownership with pro rata rights
– To maintain 0.1667% in the $12M post-money, you’d need to invest: target ownership × new post-money = 0.001667 × 12,000,000 = $20,000. Because you own half as much percentage-wise after the raise if you do not participate, you’d need to double your original $10,000 to preserve ownership.
How to size a position — simple allocation rule
1. Determine investable capital (cash you can afford to commit to private, illiquid bets). Example: $100,000.
2. Set a per-deal cap as a percentage of investable capital — common ranges: 0.5%–5%. Example: choose 2%.
3. Per-deal dollar cap = $100,000 × 2% = $2,000.
4. Portfolio limit for this asset class (crowdfunded equity) might be 5%–15% of total investable capital; adjust based on risk profile.
Pre-invest checklist (step-by-step)
1. Confirm the instrument: equity, convertible note, SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity), or debt. Understand conversion mechanics.
2. Read the offering memorandum, subscription agreement, and the company’s latest financials and cap table.
3. Check investor rights: voting, information rights, pro rata (preemptive) rights, liquidation preferences.
4. Run basic dilution math for plausible future rounds (use the worked examples above).
5. Set your allocation cap and confirm funds are not earmarked for emergencies.
6. Review platform terms, fees, transfer restrictions, and secondary-market options.
7. If unsure about tax or legal structure, consult a tax professional or securities attorney.
Post-invest monitoring and records
– Keep copies of the subscription agreement, periodic investor updates, financial statements, and tax forms.
– Track corporate events: follow-on rounds, mergers/acquisitions, secondary sales, or dissolution.
– Note tax treatment: sales/dispositions generate taxable events (capital gains/losses); consult IRS
…consult IRS guidance and your tax adviser for specifics on reporting, basis, and holding-period rules.
Ongoing oversight and watchlist items
– Watch cash runway and milestones: compare the company’s stated burn rate to actual monthly cash flow and milestone delivery (product launches, revenue targets, regulatory approvals).
– Monitor capitalization table changes: note option pool increases, convertible note conversions, and dilution from follow-on financings.
– Recordkeeping: keep digital copies of subscription agreements, transfer restrictions, Form C (for Reg CF), annual reports from the issuer, and any investor communications.
– Event triggers: be prepared to act on proxy solicitations, share buyback offers, secondary-market offers, or liquidation notices; these can create taxable events or loss realizations.
– Periodic review cadence: set quarterly reminders to review investor updates and annual reminders for tax records.
Regulatory summary (concise)
– Regulation Crowdfunding (Reg CF): a U.S. SEC rule allowing companies to raise up to $5 million in a 12‑month period from both accredited and non‑accredited investors through an SEC‑registered portal. Issuers must file Form C and provide periodic updates.
– Regulation A (Reg A+): a scaled public offering permitting raises up to $75 million (Tier 2) with more disclosure and testing-the-waters options; allows general solicitation.
– Regulation D (Rule 506(b)/(c)): private placements that generally require accredited investors and permit higher raises with fewer public-disclosure obligations.
– Non-U.S. regimes and reward/donation platforms: many countries and platforms operate under different rules; always check local securities law.
Investor limits under U.S. Reg CF — how to calculate (worked example)
SEC investor limits (summary rule; verify current thresholds when investing):
– If either annual income or net worth is less than $107,000: you may invest the greater of $2,200 or 5% of the lesser of your annual income or net worth.
– If both annual income and net worth are equal to or greater than $107,000: you may invest up to 10% of annual income or net worth, not to exceed $107,000.
Worked numeric examples:
1) Lower-income example
– Annual income = $40,000; net worth = $20,000. Lesser = $20,000.
– 5% of $20,000 = $1,000. Greater of $2,200 and $1,000 = $2,200.
– Max you may invest in all Reg CF offerings in a 12‑month period = $2,200.
2) Higher-income example
– Annual income = $150,000; net worth = $200,000. Lesser relevant for limit = you use 10% rule here.
– 10% of $150,000 = $15,000 (or 10% of net worth $200,000 = $20,000). The SEC limit is 10% of either annual income or net worth, but the investment cannot exceed $107,000 under the SEC cap. So max = min(10% calculation, $107,000) = $15,000.
Dilution and ownership math — clear steps and example
Definitions:
– Pre-money valuation: company valuation before the new money is added.
– Post-money valuation: pre-money valuation + new investment.
– Ownership percentage for new investors = new investment / post-money valuation.
Step-by-step example
– Company has 1,000,000 founder shares (100%).
– Pre-money valuation = $4,000,000. New raise = $1,000,000.
– Post-money = $4,000,000 + $1,000,000 = $5,000,000.
– New investor % = $1,000,000 / $5,000,000 = 20%.
– New total shares = founder shares / (1 – new investor %) = 1,000,000 / 0.80 = 1,250,000.
– New shares issued = 1,250,000 – 1,000,000 = 250,000.
– Founder ownership after the raise = 1,000,000 / 1,250,000 = 80% (diluted from 100% to 80%).
Pro rata example (to maintain ownership)
– Suppose an investor held 5% pre‑round. Post‑round ownership would fall unless they exercise pro rata.
– If post-money total shares = 1,250,000, 5% target = 62,500 shares.
– If the investor already owns 50,000 shares, they need to buy 12,500 new shares to maintain 5% ownership.
–
– If the investor declines the pro‑rata opportunity, their ownership percentage falls and their relative voting/influence power declines. Pro‑rata rights are common in venture deals and some equity crowdfunding offers; they are negotiated and should be spelled out in the offering documents.
Anti‑dilution protections (brief, worked example)
– Anti‑dilution protection adjusts the effective conversion price of preferred securities when new shares are sold at a lower price. Two common types: full‑ratchet and weighted‑average.
– Full‑ratchet: the original investor’s conversion price is reset to the new, lower issue price regardless of how many shares are issued. This is the strongest protection for the investor and the most dilutive to founders.
– Example: Investor bought at $2.00 per share. Company later sells shares at $1.00. Under full‑ratchet, the investor’s conversion price becomes $1.00 — they get twice as many common shares upon conversion compared with the original conversion price.
– Broad‑based weighted‑average: adjusts the conversion price based on the relative size of the new issuance; less punitive than full‑ratchet and more common.
– Formula (broad‑based weighted average): C_new = C_old × ( (Outstanding_shares + Consideration / C_old) / (Outstanding_shares + New_shares) )
– Worked numeric example:
– Outstanding_shares = 1,000,000; C_old = $2.00.
– Company issues New_shares = 100,000 at $1.00 (Consideration = $100,000).
– Consideration / C_old = 100,000 / 2 = 50,000.
– Multiplier = (1,000,000 + 50,000) / (1,000,000 + 100,000) = 1,050,000 / 1,100,000 ≈ 0.954545.
– C_new = $2.00 × 0.954545 ≈ $1.9091. The investor’s conversion price moves from $2.00 to about $1.9091 — diluted, but not as harshly as full‑ratchet.
– Note: formulas vary by contract (broad vs narrow based, whether options/warrants are included). Always check the specific language in the security purchase agreement.
Common crowdfunding structures and their investor implications (concise)
– Donation-based: contributors get no financial return; low regulatory strictness; not an investment.
– Rewards-based: backers receive a product or perk; again, not equity/debt. Risk = product never delivered.
– Equity-based: investors receive company shares or convertible securities. Key investor considerations: liquidity (illiquid), dilution, voting rights, transfer restrictions, governance, reporting frequency.
– Debt-based (peer‑to‑peer lending): investors receive interest payments and principal repayment; credit risk and platform risk matter.
– Convertible instruments (notes, SAFEs): initially act like debt or a contract that converts into equity at a future round. Conversion terms (cap, discount, valuation) determine eventual ownership —