Definition
A corporation is a legal entity created under state law that exists separately from the people who own it. Because it’s a distinct “person” in the eyes of the law, it can sign contracts, buy and sell property, hire staff, borrow money, sue and be sued, and file its own tax returns. Owners hold shares of stock; those owners are called shareholders.
Key terms (brief)
– Shareholder: an owner of one or more shares of the corporation’s stock.
– Board of directors: elected representatives of shareholders who set broad policies and hire senior management.
– Limited liability: the legal protection that ordinarily prevents shareholders from being personally responsible for the corporation’s debts and legal claims.
– Articles of incorporation: the document filed with a state to create the corporation.
– Pass-through entity: a business structure (e.g., many LLCs) where profits and losses flow to owners’ personal tax returns instead of being taxed at the entity level.
– Liquidation: the process of winding up a company, selling assets, paying creditors, and distributing any remaining funds to owners.
How a corporation works — compact explanation
– Ownership and control: Shareholders own the corporation by holding stock. They usually get voting rights (commonly one vote per share) and elect a board of directors at an annual meeting.
– Governance and management: The board sets strategy and hires senior managers (CEO, CFO, etc.) to run daily operations. Directors owe a duty of care to the company and can face consequences for serious misconduct or negligence.
– Legal capacity: The corporation acts in its own name for business activities and for tax reporting.
– Liability: The core benefit for owners is limited liability — shareholders generally are not personally on the hook for the corporation’s debts, except in rare situations involving fraud or other misconduct.
Common advantages and disadvantages
Advantages
– Limited liability for shareholders.
– Easier to raise capital by selling stock to many investors.
– Potentially useful tax treatments for certain corporations and structures.
– Helps attract employees (stock grants, option plans).
Disadvantages
– More time-consuming and costly to form and run than some other structures.
– Administrative burden: formalities such as bylaws, board meetings, and minutes.
– Potential for double taxation: profits taxed at the corporate level, and again when distributed as dividends to shareholders (depends on tax status of entity and elections made).
Forming a corporation — step-by-step checklist
1. Decide the state of incorporation (state laws and fees differ).
2. Choose a corporate name that complies with state rules.
3. Prepare and file articles of incorporation with the state agency.
4. Draft corporate bylaws (internal rules of organization).
5. Appoint initial directors (or have incorporators do it) and hold the first board meeting.
6. Issue stock to initial shareholders and record ownership.
7. Obtain an Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the IRS.
8. Open business bank accounts and set up accounting systems.
9. Apply for any required licenses or permits to operate.
10. Maintain required filings (annual reports, tax returns) and hold required meetings.
Legal and regulatory points to keep in mind
– State law primarily governs formation and corporate governance; public corporations are also regulated at the federal level (e.g., the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission).
– Shareholder voting, director duties, and many formalities are often set by state statute and the corporation’s own bylaws.
– Directors and officers may face personal liability in limited circumstances (egregious misconduct, statutory exceptions, or unpaid payroll taxes in some jurisdictions).
– Turning a private corporation into a public company requires compliance with extensive disclosure and reporting requirements.
Differences: corporation vs. other business forms
– Corporation vs. unincorporated business: A sole proprietorship or partnership is not a separate legal person; owners typically bear personal liability for business debts. Incorporating separates the business’s legal identity from owners’ personal assets.
– Corporation vs. LLC (limited liability company): Both provide limited liability. The main practical difference is taxation and formality. Many LLCs are “pass-through” entities (their profits and losses flow to owners’ personal returns). Corporations usually have more formal requirements (board, bylaws, annual meetings). Choice depends on goals for taxes, governance, capital raising, and administrative tolerance.
Operating and ending a corporation
– Operating: The board oversees the company and implements the business plan through hired management. Shareholders can influence direction through voting and meetings.
– Liquidation: To dissolve a corporation, assets are converted to cash, creditors are paid, and any remaining funds are distributed to shareholders. Liquidation can be voluntary (owners decide to close) or involuntary (creditors force liquidation; may lead to bankruptcy).
Worked numeric example — liquidation distribution
Assume a corporation winds up with the following balance:
– Total assets (sold for cash): $1,000,000
– Outstanding liabilities (creditors): $700,000
Net remaining to distribute: $1,000,000 − $700,000 = $300,000
If there are 100,000 outstanding common shares, the distribution per share = $300,000 / 100,000 = $3.00 per share. Priority rules apply: secured creditors, priority claims (e.g., certain taxes, wages) and lenders are paid before shareholders. If liabilities exceeded assets, shareholders typically receive nothing.
Worked numeric example — simple double-tax illustration (hypothetical rates)
Assume a corporation earns $100,000 of taxable profit.
1. Corporate tax (assume 21% federal only for illustration): tax = $21,000; after-tax corporate income = $79,000.
2. Corporation pays $79,000 as dividends to shareholders. If shareholders pay a 15% tax on qualified dividends: dividend tax = $79,000 × 15% = $11,850.
3. Total tax paid = $21,000 + $11,850 = $32,850, leaving shareholders with $66,150 in hand.
Notes: Tax rates and rules vary by jurisdiction and individual situation; this is a simplified
illustration of how corporate and shareholder taxes can stack.
Combined (effective) tax-rate calculation — worked numeric example
– Pre-tax corporate profit = $100,000.
– After corporate tax (21%) = $79,000.
– After shareholder dividend tax (15% on $79,000) = $66,150.
– Effective combined tax rate = 1 − (after‑tax shareholders’ receipts / pre‑tax corporate profit) = 1 − (66,150 / 100,000) = 0.3385 or 33.85%.
This single example shows the mechanical idea of “double taxation”: first at the entity level, then at the investor level when profits are distributed.
Ways corporations and owners commonly manage or reduce double taxation (overview and numeric intuition)
1. Retain earnings inside the corporation
– Effect: Defers shareholder-level tax until a future distribution or sale.
– Tradeoff: Corporation still pays corporate tax now; shareholders bear risk and timing uncertainty.
– Numeric intuition: The corporation keeps the after‑tax $79,000 to reinvest; shareholders have no immediate taxable event but may face capital gains tax later.
2. Pay owner-managers a salary rather than a dividend
– Effect: Salaries are deductible to the corporation (reducing corporate taxable income) but taxable as ordinary income to the recipient and subject to payroll taxes.
– When it helps: If the salary is reasonable for services performed, this can reduce combined tax burden compared with an undiscounted dividend.
– Caveat: Tax authorities scrutinize “sham” salaries paid solely to avoid dividend taxation.
3. Share buybacks (repurchases)
– Effect: Use corporate after‑tax cash to repurchase shares, potentially raising remaining shareholders’ equity per share.
– Tax consequence for selling shareholders: Treated as capital gains when they sell, often taxed at different rates than dividends and realized only on sale.
– Simplified numeric example: Corporation has $79,000 after tax and buys back shares. If a shareholder sells a portion and realizes a capital gain taxed at, say, 15%, that shareholder’s marginal tax may be lower or timing more favorable than receiving a dividend.
4. Elect pass‑through status (e.g., S corporation in the U.S.) or choose a pass‑through entity (LLC taxed as partnership)
– Effect: Income flows through to owners and is taxed once at individual rates.
– Limitations: Eligibility rules, limits on number/type of shareholders, and payroll-tax considerations apply.
– Example note: An S corporation’s net income is reported on shareholders’ returns; however, owner-employees must be paid reasonable compensation for services, which is subject to payroll taxes.
5. Use tax credits, deductions, and international tax planning
– Effect: Reduces corporate taxable income or offsets tax liability.
– Complexity: Often requires specialist advice; international strategies are tightly regulated and subject to anti‑avoidance rules.
Checklist for a retail trader or finance student evaluating corporate taxation effects
– Identify entity type: C corporation (subject to entity-level tax) or pass‑through (S corporation, partnership, etc.).
– Determine corporate tax rate applicable in the jurisdiction.
– Estimate whether profits will be distributed as dividends, used for buybacks, retained, or paid as salary.
– Estimate investor-level taxes (dividend vs capital gains vs ordinary income).
– Compute combined (effective) tax rate: 1 − (after-tax shareholder receipts / pre-tax corporate income).
– Consider timing: immediate dividend vs deferred capital gain can change present value.
– Factor transaction costs, compliance costs, and legal limits (e.g., S‑corp eligibility).
Practical worked comparison — dividend vs buyback (simplified)
Assume pre-tax corporate income = $100,000; corporate tax = 21% → after-tax cash = $79,000.
A. Dividend route:
– Corporation distributes $79,000 as dividend.
– Shareholder pays 15% dividend tax → receives $79,000 × (1 − 0.15) = $67,150 (rounded).
B. Buyback route:
– Corporation uses $79,000 to repurchase shares; suppose this causes a shareholder who sells to realize a capital gain taxed at 15%.
– If a shareholder sells an economically equivalent stake for $79,000, after capital gains tax they keep $79,000 × (1 − 0.15) = $67,150.
– Differences arise from timing (capital gains may be deferred), basis calculations, and whether gain is short‑term (taxed as ordinary income) or long‑term (preferential rate).
Important caveats and assumptions
– Real outcomes depend on tax-bracket differences, holding periods, basis, and local/state taxes.
– Corporate tax law changes can alter numerical results (e.g., changes to statutory rates or dividend taxation).
– Many strategies to mitigate double taxation carry legal, administrative, or economic costs and may attract regulatory scrutiny.
Quick governance and creditor priority notes (recap)
– Corporations are separate legal persons: shareholders’ liability is generally limited to capital invested.
– On liquidation, creditors and priority claimants are paid before shareholders; if liabilities exceed assets, shareholders usually receive nothing.
– Corporate formalities (board meetings, minutes, proper capitalization) help preserve limited liability; disregarding them may lead to “piercing the corporate veil” in some jurisdictions.
When to consult a professional
– Use this material as a conceptual guide. For decisions about entity type, compensation structure, cross‑border operations, or tax optimization, consult a qualified tax advisor or corporate attorney because rules are nuanced
Next steps for practitioners and founders
If you’re deciding whether to form or keep a corporation, use a structured, practical approach. Below is a concise checklist, a short numeric example that illustrates “double taxation,” common operational pitfalls to avoid, and guidance on when other entity types may be better.
Practical formation and maintenance checklist (step‑by‑step)
1. Choose jurisdiction and legal form
– Pick the state/country where you’ll incorporate (e.g., Delaware often for U.S. startups, or your home state for small businesses). Consider corporate law, filing fees, franchise taxes, and investor expectations.
2. Select a corporate name and check availability
– Confirm with the state registry and trademark databases.
3. Prepare and file incorporation documents
– File Articles (or Certificate) of Incorporation with the state and pay filing fees.
4. Adopt internal governance documents
– Draft and approve bylaws (rules for internal governance) and issue initial board resolutions.
5. Issue stock and record ownership
– Create stock certificates or electronic records, maintain a shareholder register, and consider transfer restrictions or a shareholders’ agreement.
6. Obtain federal tax ID and register for taxes
– Get an Employer Identification Number (EIN) and register for state and local taxes as required.
7. Open a corporate bank account and capitalise properly
– Keep corporate funds separate from personal funds; document any loans from founders.
8. Comply with securities, employment, and licensing laws
– For share issuances, check securities rules; for employees, follow payroll and labor regulations.
9. Maintain corporate formalities
– Hold and document board and shareholder meetings, keep minutes, file required annual reports, and pay franchise taxes.
10. Monitor capitalization and creditor exposure
– Avoid undercapitalization (having too little equity relative to likely liabilities) to help preserve limited liability protections.
Numeric example: illustrating double taxation (worked example)
Assumptions (U.S. federal rates for illustration only):
– Pre‑tax corporate income: $100,000
– Federal corporate (C corporation) tax rate: 21%
– Qualified dividend tax rate for shareholder: 15%
Step 1 — Corporate tax:
– Corporate tax = $100,000 × 21% = $21,000
– After‑tax corporate earnings available for distribution = $79,000
Step 2 — Dividend tax to shareholder:
– Dividend tax = $79,000 × 15% = $11,850
Total tax paid (federal, illustrative) = $21,000 + $11,850 = $32,850
Effective combined tax rate on pre‑tax profit = $32,850 / $100,000 = 32.85%
Contrast: pass‑through (S corporation or LLC taxed as partnership)
– If the $100,000 flowed directly to the owner’s individual return taxed at, say, 24% marginal rate: tax = $100,000 × 24% = $24,000.
– Net to owner = $76,000 (higher than the C‑corp after the two levels above in this numeric example).
Note: Real outcomes depend on state taxes, qualified dividend treatment, capital gains rules, deductible expenses, payroll tax implications for S‑corp wages, and other factors. This example is illustrative; actual tax consequences vary.
Common operational and legal pitfalls (short checklist)
– Commingling assets: Never mix personal and corporate funds or assets.
– Under‑documented decisions: Failing to hold or document meetings and resolutions erodes protections.
– Undercapitalization: Funding the company with too little equity increases risk of veil piercing claims by creditors.
– Improper securities compliance: Issuing stock without complying with securities registration or exemptions can create liability.
– Misclassification of workers: Treating employees as independent contractors can trigger back taxes and penalties.
– Ignoring payroll and withholding obligations: Missing payroll taxes is a frequent and costly error.
– Poor shareholder agreements: Not defining transfer restrictions, vesting, buy‑sell terms, and dispute resolution leads to later conflict.
When to consider alternatives to a standard C corporation
– You want simple pass‑through taxation and fewer formalities: consider an LLC or S corporation (S corporation availability has restrictions — e.g., number and type of shareholders).
– You want venture capital and public listing potential: many investors prefer C corporations (especially Delaware C corps for U.S. VC-backed startups).
– You’re a single-owner small business with low liability risk: a sole proprietorship or single‑member LLC can be simpler and cheaper.
– Cross‑border operations: consider tax treaties, permanent establishment rules, and where to locate holding companies. Consult an international tax specialist.
Practical decision checklist for entity selection
– Estimate total tax burden (federal + state + local) under each structure.
–
– Model cash needs and owner compensation. Decide how much profit you’ll pay out as salary (subject to payroll taxes) versus distributions/dividends (subject to dividend or pass‑through tax rules). Payroll taxes (employer + employee portions) apply to wages; dividends and pass‑through distributions are taxed differently. Estimate realistic cash drawings for the next 3–5 years.
– Compute the effective total tax (corporate + owner) under likely scenarios. That means: corporate income tax on entity profits, then personal tax on any distributions. Include surtaxes such as the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT) where relevant, and consider state and local income/franchise taxes.
– Check eligibility for key tax rules and credits. For pass‑throughs this includes the Section 199A qualified business income (QBI) deduction (up to 20% subject to limits). For C corporations consider R&D
credit and the Section 41 R&D tax credit (carryforwards and payroll tax offsets for small startups). Also check credits or incentives at the state level (film, energy, job‑creation credits), and charitable deduction limits for C corporations.
How to estimate combined (entity + owner) tax cost — step‑by‑step
1) Define the economic profit number (P). This is pre‑owner cash available for wages, distributions, or retained earnings for the next 3–5 years. State your assumptions (growth, seasonality).
2) Decide owner cash draw strategy for each year:
– Salary (W): subject to payroll taxes (employee + employer portions) and ordinary income tax on the owner.
– Distributions/dividends (D): taxed at shareholder rates (qualified dividend rates or pass‑through rules).
– Retained earnings (R): taxed at the entity level now; taxed on distribution later.
Make sure P = W + distributions declared + retained earnings.
3) Compute corporate tax on taxable income:
– Corporate taxable income = P − deductible salaries − allowed deductions/credits.
– Corporate tax = Tc × corporate taxable income − credits (Tc is statutory corporate rate, e.g., 21% federally).
4) Compute owner payroll taxes on wages:
– Employer + employee payroll taxes apply to wages (split matters for cash cost to the business vs net pay to owner).
– Note Social Security wage base limits and Medicare (no cap for Medicare).
5) Compute owner income tax on salary and on distributions:
– Salary taxed at ordinary personal rates.
– Dividends: qualified dividends taxed at long‑term capital gain rates if holding/qualification rules met; else ordinary rates. Pass‑through distributions may be eligible for Section 199A QBI deduction (up to 20% subject to limits).
– Apply NIIT (Net Investment Income Tax) of 3.8% to applicable investment income above thresholds.
6) Sum total taxes (corporate tax + payroll taxes + owner federal income tax + NIIT + state/local taxes) and divide by economic profit P to get an effective combined tax rate.
7) Run sensitivity checks: vary W (higher salary reduces corporate tax but increases payroll and personal ordinary income tax) and vary distributions to find tax‑efficient mix subject to legal reasonableness (IRS requires reasonable salary for S corporations and payroll reporting rules).
Worked numeric example (simplified) — compare C corporation vs pass‑through
Assumptions (explicit):
– Economic profit P = $500,000 for the year.
– Federal corporate tax rate Tc = 21%.
– Owner takes salary W = $150,000; remaining cash distributed as dividends.
– Owner is single; assume qualified dividend tax rate = 15%; assume marginal ordinary income tax rate on salary = 24% (these are assumptions for illustration).
– Employer payroll taxes (employer share of FICA/employer Medicare) paid by the corporation = 7.65% on wages; employee FICA withheld = 7.65% (we’ll include both for total payroll cost).
– Ignore state taxes and credits for clarity; ignore corporate deductibility differences other than salary.
C corporation path
1) Corporate taxable income before tax = P − W = 500,000 − 150,000 = 350,000.
2) Corporate federal tax = 21% × 350,000 = 73,500.
3) After‑tax corporate cash available for distribution = 350,000 − 73,500 = 276,500.
4) Owner personal taxes:
– On salary: ordinary income tax ≈ 24% × 150,000 = 36,000.
– Payroll taxes (both shares as total economic cost): 15.3% × 150,000 = 22,950.
– On dividends: 15% × 276,500 = 41,475.
5) Total taxes (rounded) = corporate tax 73,500 + salary income tax 36,000 + payroll 22,950 + dividend tax 41,475 = 173,925.
6) Effective combined tax rate = 173,925 / 500,000 = 34.8%.
Pass‑through (S corporation or single‑member LLC taxed as sole proprietor — simplified)
Assumptions for comparison:
– Owner takes “reasonable” salary W = $150,000 and remaining business profit of P − W = 350,000 is reported as pass‑through income/distribution
Taxes for the pass‑through scenario (S corporation — simplified)
7) Owner payroll and income taxes (S‑corp structure, distributions not subject to payroll taxes)
– Payroll taxes on salary: 15.3% × 150,000 = 22,950.
– Income tax on salary: 24% × 150,000 = 36,000.
– Income tax on pass‑through profit (P − W = 350,000): 24% × 350,000 = 84,000.
8) Total taxes (pass‑through, rounded) = payroll 22,950 + salary income tax 36,000 + pass‑through income tax 84,000 = 142,950.
9) Effective combined tax rate (pass‑through) = 142,950 / 500,000 = 28.6%.
Comparison and intuition
– C‑corporation combined effective tax (from earlier) = 34.8% of pre‑tax business earnings.
– S‑